Best Smokers Under 500 Of 2023
Dart Hill Sep 28, 2023 10:07 PM
The act of preparing a meal together is a powerful unifier of social groups. Cigarette smokers are at the epicenter of the devices that make this possible. Meats, veggies, and bread smoked in one of the best smokers under $500 will have an intense flavor that can't be achieved any other way. The flavor of even the most affordable cigarettes can rival that of the most expensive gourmet restaurants. Therefore, cost should not be seen as an indicator of quality.
If you have your own smoker, you can create your own unique flavor profiles for smoked foods. If you use it frequently, you'll figure out how to get the flavor you want by adjusting the amount of wood and the type of marinade you use. Owning a smoker is the first step in fulfilling your dream of competing in barbecue contests. Choosing a smoker may seem like a daunting task, but we'll walk you through the process step by step, explaining why factors like smoker size, material, maximum temperature, and power source are crucial and how they'll effect the final product.
During our testing, we had more fun than we have in a long time and sampled a wide variety of smokey flavors. We learned a lot from our time spent in the kitchen alongside professional chefs. We're passing along their knowledge on how to pick the best smoker to you. Here you'll find a comprehensive buying guide, detailed evaluations of each smoker, and a comparison table to help you select the best smokers available for less than $500.
Compare Products
- SCORE9.6
- BrandWeber
- Prime
- SCORE9.4
- BrandChar-Griller
- Prime
- SCORE9.0
- BrandMasterbuilt
- Prime
- SCORE9.0
- BrandMasterbuilt
- Prime
- SCORE9.0
- BrandDyna-Glo
- Prime
- SCORE9.0
- BrandDyna-Glo
- Prime
- SCORE9.0
- BrandCuisinart
- Prime
- SCORE9.0
- BrandPIT BOSS
- Prime
- SCORE9.0
- BrandSmokehouse
- Prime
- SCORE8.8
- BrandMasterbuilt
- Prime
- SCORE8.8
- BrandMasterbuilt
- SCORE8.8
- BrandChar-Broil
- Prime
- SCORE8.6
- BrandPIT BOSS
- Prime
Last update on 2023-09-28 / Affiliate links / Images, Product Titles, and Product Highlights from Amazon Product Advertising API
Build Quality and Design
The best smokers are built to last and have tight seals to keep the smoke and heat inside. Quality smokers are often made of steel and coated in powder or enamel to protect from elements like rain and extreme heat. Both the Pit Barrel Cooker and the Weber Smokey Mountain have excellent enamel, and the steel construction is as sturdy as it gets.
Consistent Temperatures
It is useless if a smoker cannot maintain a low and constant ambient smoking temperature. For newcomers, the ideal temperature range is between 225 and 250 degrees Fahrenheit, and it should be maintained at this level continuously. How well a smoker is able to keep temperatures stable depends on factors such as its design, fuel, construction, seal, and air intake. Drum and bullet smokers, for instance, produce more evenly cooked food than offset smokers.
Again, our top picks—the Weber Smokey Mountain and the Pit Barrel Cooker—came out on top. The Pit Barrel Cooker reached temperatures somewhat higher than 225 degrees Fahrenheit, yet it burned steadily and ultimately cooked meat much more quickly than most low and slow smokers. Thanks to its pellet smoker construction, the Camp Chef DLX did well, too. The Dyna Glo's inconsistency stems from its poor sealing performance (but cheap price tag of under $300).
Size and Cooking Area
When hosting a large gathering of relatives, it makes sense to spend the day smoking a large quantity of meat. If you don't plan on cooking on the road very often, choose a charcoal or wood smoker with a large cooking grate for your first attempt.
The Dyna-Glo is the best cheap smoker since it has the most cooking space (almost 1000 square inches) and the least expensive price tag. It has 5 stacked racks for even more cooking space. Its ability to hang slabs of meat makes up for the Pit Barrel Cooker's limited cooking space. Since it was the smallest of the Green Mountain Grills, the Davy Crockett was best reserved for on-the-go meat smoking due to its small 219 square inch cooking area. Other smokers on the list have cooking areas ranging from 560 square inches down to 300 square inches.
Fuel Type
All of these smokers rely on wood for their smoke, but there are several ways to heat the wood. Charcoal smokers are more classic, while electric smokers are more practical. One further choice is a gas barbecue. Due to the fact that wood is what imparts flavor, the choice of fuel is more a matter of taste.
Portability
You probably won't be moving your smoker very far, but having the ability to put it away when it's not in use or relocate it to a more favorable place in the yard when the wind picks up is useful. Consider whether you can lift the smoker by yourself or whether you will require assistance.
Ability to Cold Smoke
Although most smokers have no trouble lighting up a hot cigarette, chilly smoking can be a bit more challenging. Is it cold-smoked salmon or bacon you're after, or perhaps some smoked and cooked pork or beef ribs or brisket? There's no point in seeking out smokers who have access to cold smoking if you have no plans to try it yourself.
Material
Cheaper smokers are generally built from stainless steel. However, there is a significant disparity between the various grades of stainless steel. Find the thicker, stronger stainless steel that is the industry standard. Thinner, lower-gauge stainless steel might lose heat more easily, reducing the smoker's efficiency.
Weight
The vast majority of home smoking devices are portable and lightweight. Just be aware that some of them are really large and won't fit in your pocket easily. You should always check the weight before making a purchase. You don't want to get a smoker that is so cumbersome to move that you're stuck with it wherever you put it.
Water pan
The water pan is located between the stove or oven and the cooking area, and is usually half full of water. It mediates between the heat source and the food, soaking up excess heat (so that it doesn't all go into the food and burn it) and keeping everything at the right temperature when the source cools down. Food is also protected from drying out. Efficiency increases with the quality of the water pan.
Vents
To regulate the flow of air into and out of the smoker, vents are required. The best chimneys feature three openings at the base and one opening at the top. The air that enters the smoker from the bottom helps to sustain the fire. When the temperature within the smoker rises too high, opening the top vent allows the excess heat to escape.
What's the best way to store a smoker?
A smoke detector should be kept in a cool, dry place. An enclosed space like a garage or garden shed is perfect for smoking, but any outdoor location with adequate protection from the elements will do. Most smokers have covers available to assist keep your equipment dry and clean; however, a waterproof tarp can serve the same purpose in a situation. Always give your smoker a good scrub off before putting it away for an extended amount of time.
Are Traegers worth the money?
Despite the fact that the Traeger brand is still the most widely recognized name in pellet smokers, many barbeque fans believe that the high price tag is no longer justified. There is a general agreement that Traeger's competitors are worthy of consideration because of a decline in construction quality and the idea that customers are mostly funding Traeger's advertising expenditure.
What foods can you smoke?
Most people's minds go straight to barbecue when you mention smoking meat. This might be anything from beef brisket to pig and spare ribs to beef short ribs or hog shoulders. These fatty cuts become soft, smoke-flavored treats when cooked at low temperatures for several hours, according to Lang. Although, BBQ isn't the only option. Smoking not only produces tasty meats, but also fish, sausage, and cheese.
How do you clean a smoker?
A wire brush for the grill, a wet/dry vacuum, and a lot of hard work are all you need to clean the grill. Smokers are more prone to buildup from combustion due to their long cooking times, according to Lang. This motivates him to disassemble his smoker after every four or five uses, clean it well, and then put it back together again. To quickly remove any lingering ash from the smoker, many people turn to a portable wet/dry vacuum. "It really helps save time and keeps things clean for the next cook," explains Lang.
When prepared at home, smoked treats take on a whole new flavor profile. The correct smoker will make quick work of even the most ambitious menu items.
With any luck, you'll find a model on this list of the finest smokes under $500 that's just right for your needs and preferences.
